Completed Studies

Research that’s made a difference—shaping the future of pediatric surgery.

The Midwest Pediatric Surgery Research Consortium has successfully completed numerous multi-institutional studies addressing critical issues in pediatric surgical care. These collaborative efforts have produced valuable insights, informed clinical guidelines, and contributed to improved outcomes for children nationwide. Explore the impactful work that continues to guide best practices in our field.

Anorectal Malformations

  • Anorectal Malformations (ARM) occur in up to 1 in 4000 live births and encompass a spectrum ranging from anal stenosis to imperforate anus to cloacal exstrophy. They are often associated with other congenital anomalies, such as the VACTERL cluster, which are important determinants of prognosis and should be evaluated in all patients. Minneci et al. used the MWPSC group to study the frequency of various ARM defects and associated anomalies in 506 patients. They found that ARM with perineal fistula was the most common phenotype comprising 41% of patients. 96% of ARM patients had at least one screening test for associated anomalies and 11% underwent screening for all VACTERL associated anomalies. The most common associated anomaly was cardiac with PFO, PDA, and ASD being found in 58%, 44%, and 21% of patients respectively. Other organ systems were less common but still frequently involved and included hydronephrosis (23%), tethered spinal cord (21%), and sacral dysplasia (18%). This provided important information supporting the screening for associated anomalies in ARM patients.

    Long-term patient and family satisfaction around ARM procedures is heavily weighted towards fecal continence. Families are counseled that ARMs are lifetime conditions, and that bowel management is a component, but specifics are difficult. The MWPSC sought to study whether fecal continence can be predicted in these patients. In 2019, Minneci et al. studied 144 patients from the consortium centers and used multivariable logistic regression to look for factors associated with continence. Only 40% of patients studied were classified as continent. Factors associated with continence were the type and severity of ARM. Patients with ARM with perineal fistula were the most likely to have fecal continence (60%).

    Sacral Ratios as a measure of sacral development have been used to help predict disease severity and continence in previous studies, however, the interpretation of images is subjective. The MWPSC looked at inter-rater reliability (IRR) of sacral ratio to help improve accuracy as a predictive test. In 2020, Metzger et al. looked at sacral imaging from 263 patients from consortium centers. They found that the reliability and predictive value were higher for the AP views compared to lateral (IRR 82% vs. 44%). This study has been important for standardizing imaging interpretations and providing information to better counsel families on results.

    Publications

    • Minneci PC, Kabre RS, Mak GZ, Halleran DR, Cooper JN, Afrazi A, et al. Screening practices and associated anomalies in infants with anorectal malformations: Results from the Midwest Pediatric Surgery Consortium. Journal of Pediatric Surgery 2018;53:1163–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2018.02.079.

    • Minneci PC, Kabre RS, Mak GZ, Halleran DR, Cooper JN, Afrazi A, et al. Can fecal continence be predicted in patients born with anorectal malformations? Journal of Pediatric Surgery 2019;54:1159–63. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2019.02.035.

    • Metzger G, Cooper JN, Kabre RS, Mak GZ, Halleran DR, Boyd K, et al. Inter-rater Reliability of Sacral Ratio Measurements in Patients with Anorectal Malformations. Journal of Surgical Research 2020;256:272–81. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jss.2020.06.040.

Management of Spontaneous Pneumothorax

  • Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax (PSP) occurs in up to 1 in 6000 males and 1 in 16,000 females. The etiology is thought to be from rupture of thin-walled blebs or bubbles in the lungs and presents with sharp pain on the affected side. Depending on size and symptoms, there are many ways of managing this but traditionally, it has been done with a chest tube to suction out the air and let the lung re-expand. There have been several adult studies that have shown the majority of these resolved without intervention if the pneumothorax did not expand under a period of observation. The MWPSC sought to examine whether simple aspiration or removing the air once was predictive of resolution or need for surgery. In 2019, Leys et al. created a prospective protocol to test aspiration through a pigtail catheter followed by a 6-hour observation period with the tube clamped. 33 patients were managed on this protocol. The aspiration test was successful in 48% of patients and they were able to go home after the observation period. PSP did recur in 44% of the patients who passed the initial test. Of the patients that failed the initial test, 30% went directly to surgical intervention and 70% were managed with admission and a chest tube.

    Of the patients admitted and managed with a chest tube, 83% had a recurrence of PSP and went on to surgical intervention. This study showed that initial aspiration as management is safe and if successful, has about 50% recurrence. If the initial aspiration test fails, it is predictive of needing surgical intervention.

Congenital Lung Malformations

  • Congenital Lung Malformations (CLM) may occur in up to 1 in 2000 live births and include several sub-types such as Congenital Pulmonary Airway Malformations (CPAM), Bronchopulmonary Sequestration (BPS), Congenital Lobar Emphysema (CLE), and Bronchogenic Cysts. They have a range of clinical presentations from lesions that may go undiagnosed until chest imaging is done for other purposes, to recurrent infections, to life-threatening respiratory distress after birth. These malformations have traditionally been managed with surgical resection both to prevent future complications and concern of progression into a race cancer called Pleuropulmonary Blastoma (PPB), however, outcomes from resection and other features of surgical management have not had large patient studies and the MWPSC chose to investigate this.

    In 2018 Kunisaki et al. utilized the MWPSC to create a multi-institutional registry of children who underwent surgery for all types of CLM. They were able to study 506 children and studied all aspects of the disease from fetal diagnosis and treatment through post-operative care and follow-up. They were able to describe that 90% of resections occur outside of the neonatal period and were mostly elective. Surgical resections had an all-complication rate of approximately 18% with residual pneumothorax requiring chest tube as the most common occurring in 8% of cases. Complication rates were highest in the neonatal period. This registry also served as a dataset for future studies. In 2019 Kunisaki et al. focused on the operative management of CLE specifically due to the severity of its peri-natal presentation. Using the registry, they were able to find 53 patients with CLE, the largest study of this pathologic sub-type. They found that compared to other congenital lung malformations, prenatal diagnosis was less common for CLE and that ultrasound was not specific for CLE. Neonates with CLE were three times as likely to have respiratory symptoms at birth and to have neonatal resection compared to other CLM lesions. Data on operative management also identified variability in the approach between open and thoracoscopic resections. This led to a study by Weller et al. that looked at outcomes between the two approaches. They found that thoracoscopic approaches were becoming more common and that while they had longer operative times, they required less epidural anesthesia and had no increase in post-operative complications. This has led to an increase in minimally invasive approaches for these children.

    Prenatal screening and management of CLM are variables based on institution. Kunisaki et al. focused on this aspect of management in a 2020 study aimed at risk stratification. They were able to show that Congenital Pulmonary Airway Malformation Volume Ratio (CVR) was predictive of postnatal course although CVR measurements were only available for half of the patients identified. The authors found that a cutoff CVR of greater than 2.25 had a 100% sensitivity for detecting fetal hydrops whereas a CVR of below 1.36 had almost a 100% prediction for not developing fetal hydrops. The initial and maximum CVR was found to be associated with respiratory symptoms at birth, need for supplemental oxygen, preoperative neonatal ventilator use, and neonatal lung resection, although the ideal CVR cutoff is different for each outcome. The authors were able to use this data to generate a decision tree to help patients and providers with prenatal counseling and to decide on a delivery facility.

    Lastly, one of the major drivers for elective resection is a concern for PPB, however, its exact risk and prevalence were unknown. Kunisaki et al. looked at the pathology of 521 lung lesions. PPB was identified in 8.7 % of postnatally diagnosed CLM. They found that if CT imaging is suggestive of malignancy, then the lung lesion was likely malignant, however, CT imaging was not sensitive. The higher-than-expected malignancy rate for postnatally diagnosed CLM has led providers to consider operative management for more of these patients. CLM remains an active area of study with ongoing analysis and publications of our registry.